'Summer House' Finale: Kyle Confronts Amanda Over ‘Emotional Affair' With West

The Summer House season 10 finale showed the beginning of the end for Kyle Cooke and Amanda Batula's marriage - but it's Kyle's comments about West Wilson that have fans talking.

During the Tuesday, May 19, finale, the summer scenes ended on September 1, 2025. The cameras picked up seven months later, following Kyle, 43, and Amanda's split announcement in January and Amanda, 34, and West's relationship confirmation in March.

"You're looking skinny. I'm worried about you," Kyle tells Amanda in the April 9 footage after she comes over to his place days after she and West, 31, went public with their romance. (West previously dated Summer House's Ciara Miller, one of Amanda's best friends, which added to the drama and public backlash the couple received following their romance reveal.)

"I'm worried about me too," Amanda admits.

The exes then have a heart-to-heart about their own relationship, with Kyle claiming, "I look back at this summer and it looked like you were done with me."

Amanda alleged, "I gave our relationship everything I had."

She explained, "The idea of me existing with you in my life was so impossible for me to wrap my head around and made it so hard to call it quits. … I was so afraid that once we ended things we'd just be out of our lives forever and I couldn't handle that."

Kyle pointed out that for him, there are certain "instances" from summer 2025 and the fall where he felt like Amanda "wasn't just one foot out, she was fully out the door."

Kyle questioned, "Says who?" Amanda alleged, "There's a video," to which Kyle responded, "OK."

"My point is, I would never do that to someone else," Amanda added, once again shutting down any possibility that she and West's romance began earlier than they are letting on.

Kyle told Amanda, "I know you're not a bad person. I think you were reckless and thoughtless," but he reminded her that he'll always "worry" about her and "care" about her.

"It's not your responsibility but I appreciate that," Amanda replied, noting, "I care about you in the same f***ing way."

An emotional Kyle then confessed that the whole West situation "makes me so f***ing upset." He paused for a minute and then added, "That someone else gets the version that I fell in love with."

As fans of Summer House know, season 10 was filmed in summer 2025. In January, Kyle and Amanda announced they were divorcing after four years of marriage.

Two months later, rumors swirled that Amanda was seeing West after he dated Ciara, 30, back in 2023 and as the exes flirted throughout season 10. (Ciara and West even kissed during the season finale, which filmed in late August 2025.)

Us Weekly reported in April that West and Ciara had been hooking up as recently as "about three to four weeks ago," and she had no knowledge of his relationship with Amanda.

West and Amanda will face their Summer House costars for the first time publicly at the season 10 reunion, which will air in three parts beginning on May 26.

In the official trailer for the reunion, released on Tuesday, Ciara called out Amanda for her betrayal and claimed West was trying to mess with her after their ups and downs.

"Over the past six years, I have been your f***ing champion," Ciara told Amanda in the trailer. "I couldn't fathom that I would be sitting here pissed that you're f***ing my ex."

Ciara then claimed that West "wants to embarrass me. He wants to get his last little word. And I hope it works because he's with you to spite me."

Part 1 of the Summer House season 10 reunion will air on Bravo Tuesday, May 26, at 8 p.m. ET.

Copyright 2026 Us Weekly. All rights reserved

This story was originally published May 19, 2026 at 9:01 PM.